Intrabar path ambiguity needs a predeclared resolution policy
OHLC extrema cannot always settle event order, causal availability or the executable quantity of a short-term rule.
A bar is a summary with a source contract
Open, high, low and close compress observations under a declared sampling convention. They may not reveal the order of every intrabar event. Save venue/product, price object, interval, completion and availability before testing a rule. The publication has no licensed intraday archive and invents no finer path to repair missing order. The original calendar/bar lesson remains the broad starting point. This investigation focuses on choosing resolution before outcomes rather than treating a later detailed chart as if it were part of the original study.
Two plausible paths can support one bar
A high and low can occur in different orders while leaving the same extrema. If a rule's economic interpretation requires that order, the missing sequence is an evidence gap. Do not always assume the target preceded the stop or assign the best later fill. A genuine study retains the frozen research observation-window convention rather than silently extending it. Selected simulation documentation describes model behaviour, not proof of an actual account path. The new amount lens accepts declared fragments and does not construct their chronology or choose a hypothetical fill engine.
Higher resolution is not automatically eligible
Additional data still needs source identity, rights, warmup, availability and a compatible native execution contract. It cannot be introduced only for favourable or adverse cases after inspecting outcomes. Preserve missing periods and effective versions. Software tests of a bar parser or equation are not independently sampled strategy observations. Real asset work must integrate and certify the appropriate route through its authorised factory. The educational cases contain no real bar, trade sequence, calibrated probability or completed financial master, so no empirical performance conclusion can follow from their apparent detail.
Write the unresolved result explicitly
A review can identify that the bar cannot settle a required event order and request the authentic permitted-resolution source. That finding is useful even without a profitable outcome. Keep original rule, exit and exclusions fixed; do not reopen a tournament of favourable interpretation policies after validation. The ten-field workbench can record the gap without turning documented notes into account verification. The fictional paths below illustrate ambiguity only. They do not assert actual stop execution, venue failure, real market behaviour or a maximum-loss guarantee for a chosen position.
Fictional short-horizon evidence case
Invented bar open 100, high 103, low 97, close 101 can fit a path reaching high first or low first. A teaching question requiring the first boundary interaction is unresolved from those extrema alone. No actual candle, broker execution or financial outcome is supplied, and neither path is chosen to improve a result.
| Object | Record | Bounded finding |
|---|---|---|
| Path A | High before low assumed | One possible fiction |
| Path B | Low before high assumed | Another possible fiction |
| Required order | Not in extrema | Source needed |

Primary references and scope
Source review: 14 October 2026. Official mechanism descriptions are not this desk's paid-account test, independently captured fills or vendor-return audit.